TaxProf, NY Times: it Is Time to Raise Taxes on Everybody — Including the Middle Class. Paul Caron links to a New York Times Op-ed:
To make ends meet, both parties agree, spending must be drastically cut. Under the White House budget proposal, discretionary spending on everything except the military is projected to shrink to its smallest share of the economy since the Eisenhower administration by the beginning of the next decade. Though he has resisted Republican demands to slash entitlements, President Obama remains willing to look for further savings from Medicare.
This is not, however, the only option we have. There is an alternative: raising more money from all taxpayers, including the middle class.
Nobody wants to talk about this. … Yet Americans would benefit from a discussion of this possibility.
It’s not true that “both parties agree” that spending must be drastically cut. It’s not clear that either party, as a whole, admits it, and at least one party remains in firm denial. The President’s campaign was all about spending money and sending the bill to the rich guy. Still, it’s nice that finally somebody at the New York Times admits that the rich guy isn’t buying. He can’t.
Janet Novack, As IRS Tax Filing Season Begins, Bad News For Honest Taxpayers. She speaks with Taxpayer Advocate Nina Olson. The article has some depressing truth:
Customer service at the Internal Revenue Service is dismal and deteriorating. (Only 68% of telephone callers who wanted to talk to a human at the IRS last tax filing season eached one, and then only after an average 17 minute wait.) The epidemic of identity theft refund fraud hasn’t yet been contained. Hope for a major reform that might simplify the tax code is waning.
The article also has some serious nonsense about last week’s ruling shutting down the IRS preparer regulation power grab:
“If the injunction stands, the taxpayers of the United States will be grievously harmed,” IRS National Taxpayer Advocate Nina E. Olson told Forbes. “The practical effect of not having some kind of consumer protection for taxpayers going to return preparers is enormous. And I say that seeing all the return preparer fraud, and the return preparer negligence, and the return preparer inadvertent mistakes that happen.”
Enormous? More like what we did forever until two years ago. If anybody has evidence that last year’s tax preparers were significantly more accomplished and accurate than they were before the regulations, they haven’t shared it. And the idea that the RTRP
literacy competency test and minimal CPE requirement would have changed that is silly.
Ms. Olson believes that depriving consumers of choices in preparers is in their interest because the diminished choices would be better. That flies in the face of all we know about regulation. The net result would be higher prices, driving more taxpayers to do their returns and driving some on the margins out of the system altogether, while sending more business to the big franchise tax prep outfits.
Robert D. Flach, TAX RETURN PREPARER REGULATION, LICENSURE, AND/OR CERTIFICATION. Robert’s magnum opus on how tax preparers should be regulated.
While I agree that having the Internal Revenue Service regulate tax preparers is not the best option – it is without a doubt a far superior option to having Congress legislate regulation. My opinion of the intelligence, competence, and ability, or rather lack of intelligence, competence, and ability, of the current members of Congress is well known.The optimal source of tax preparer regulation/licensure/certification, whether mandatory or voluntary, would be an independent industry-based organization, not unlike the AICPA or ABA, such as the National Institute of Registered Tax Return Preparers that I have proposed.
Robert also calls me out:
As I have asked in response to Joe’s assertion, would you want a “casual” electrician wiring your kitchen, or a “casual” dentist filling a cavity, or a “casual” architect designing your home?
If I do, what business is it of anybody else? If I want to pay a talented handyman neighbor or cousin to install a ceiling fan for me, why is it anybody’s business? Why should he be not allowed to take my money just because he doesn’t have an electrician card from the Bureau of Electrical and Mortuary Science? As TaxGrrrl noted yesterday, occupational licensing is taking over the economy, and that’s not a good thing.
Cara Griffith, Have State Income Taxes Run Their Course? (Tax.com)
The corporate income tax is inefficient and a not sufficiently stable source of revenue for states. It should be eliminated. The individual income tax is likewise not a particularly stable source of revenue for states, and while counterintuitive, progressive tax systems do not work well at the state-level. Income redistribution, to the extent that it should be a goal at all, should not be undertaken at the state-level. So in a perfect world, yes, the state individual income tax should be eliminated as well.
Christopher Bergin agrees.
Good. Another bid to ban traffic enforcement cameras in Iowa. (O. Kay Henderson, via The Beanwalker). Traffic cameras are your local government’s most sincere way of showing their contempt for you.
Trish McIntire, Form 8332 and Fairness. How the IRS enables bitter ex-spouses.
Paul Neiffer, Why Imputed Interest Matters For 2013 (And Beyond)
Kaye A. Thomas, Another Demutualization Case
Robert W. Wood, Golfer Phil Mickelson Is Not Alone In Fleeing Taxes (Via Kerry Kerstetter)
Peter Reilly, Why Phil Mickelson’s Remark Was Really Dumb
Brian Mahany, Is FATCA In Trouble? Unfortunately, NO
Joseph Henchman, CBPP’s Misleading Chart on Debt Stabilization (Tax Policy Blog). A study in cherry-picking.
Jen Carrigan, Should Capital Gains Be Taxed Differently? (Guest post at The Missouri Taxguy blog).
Patrick Temple-West, Firms keep stockpiles of ‘foreign’ cash in U.S., and more
News you can use: Passing the CPA Exam While Billing Over 2500 Hours in a Year Is Way Harder Than Having a Baby. (Going Concern). Also less useful and not as smart.
Tags: Brian Mahany, Cara Griffith, Going Concern, Janet Novack, Jen Carrigan, Josehp Henchman, Kay Bell, Kaye Thomas, Kerry Kerstetter, Nina Olson, O Kay Henderson, Patrick Temple-West, Paul Neiffer, Peter Reilly, preparer regulation, Robert D Flach, Robert Wood, Tax Trials, TaxGrrrl, TaxProf, the rich guy's not buying, Trish McIntire