So I took a five-day weekend. I needed the sleep, and to see something besides the office, my bed, and my commuting route. So now to clear the debris of the last few weeks from my desk, and my email inbox.
And I come back to see perhaps the dumbest thing ever to come out of the Tax Court. Janet Novack reports:
“Taxpayers rely on IRS guidance at their own peril,” Judge Joseph W. Nega wrote in an order entered on April 15th —an order denying a motion that he reconsider his earlier decision to penalize tax lawyer Alvan L. Bobrow for making an IRA rollover move that IRS Publication 590, Individual Retirement Arrangements (IRAs), says is allowed.
Which is more astounding: he IRS decision to seek penalties against a taxpayer for following IRS guidance, or the Tax Court going along? A great deal of what we do as professionals, and what taxpayers do, is in reliance on IRS guidance, because often that’s all there is to go on. If you can get hit with a penalty for following IRS guidance if the IRS changes its mind, we’re all avoiding disaster only as long as the IRS is in a good mood.
This unwittingly goes to the heart of the IRS non-enforcement of the Obamacare employer mandate. The statute provides that the penalty tax on those with 50 or more employees starts this year if they fail to provide specified health insurance. Nothing in the statute provides otherwise. The only thing standing between all these employers and massive penalties is IRS guidance — y0u know, the guidance that Judge Nega just said taxpayers rely on “at their own peril.”
The whole Tax Court should reconsider this order. If they decide that something that stupid really is the law, Congress should reverse with legislation providing that taxpayers relying on written IRS guidance should never be penalized for it.
There are basically three types of tax trouble. There is “I was underwithheld at work because my salary changed over the course of the year but didn’t realize it” or “I’m a freelancer or small-business owner, and I forgot to put away enough money for taxes, or I incorrectly estimated what my tax bill would be.” Then there is “I am a small-business owner or otherwise self-employed, and I am on the brink of financial collapse; the money with which I hoped to pay the taxes had to go to keep my creditors (barely) at bay.” And, of course, though I hope this is not you, there is “I have been cheating on my taxes.”
She notes that different troubles require different solutions.
Thanks to her link, and to one from Instapundit to the same post, last week was the busiest around here all year. My thanks to them, and to everyone who takes the time to link here. You rock my little world. If you ever want to link to just a piece of a Tax Roundup, you can do so if it starts in blue bold letters, like the words “Megan McArdle” at the beginning of this segment.
While I was too busy to do Tax Roundups at the end of tax season, I missed some excellent Bozo Tax Tips from Russ Fox, including Bozo Tax Tip #1: The Eternal Hobby Loss
Greg Mankiw,Transitory Income and the One Percent:
It turns out that 12 percent of the population will find themselves in the top 1 percent of the income distribution for at least one year. What’s more, 39 percent of Americans will spend a year in the top 5 percent of the income distribution, 56 percent will find themselves in the top 10 percent, and a whopping 73 percent will spend a year in the top 20 percent of the income distribution….
-Quoting a NY Times article by Mark Rank
Jason Dinesen, Another Tax Season Down — 2014 Tax Season Recap
Paul Neiffer, Another Tax Season Bites the Dust. “This year was actually much easier on myself and I think most of my compatriots since we did not have Congress passing a tax bill on the last day of the year to mess up the IRS computers (although the computers have other issues to deal with).”
Robert D. Flach, THAT WAS THE TAX SEASON THAT WAS. “43 down – 7 to go!” I hope to stop before 43, myself. Robert is tougher than I am.
In case you missed it, you can see my April 15 interview with local TV station KCCI here.
Tony Nitti, Tax Geek Tuesday: Tax Planning For Mergers And Acquisitions, Part I. “…if we spend the time necessary to uncover and understand our clients’ non-tax and tax goals, we will typically find that choosing an ideal transaction structure is largely a process of elimination, and when the dust settles, there will often be only one option that works.”
Peter Reilly, Sawyer Taxi Heirs Midcoast Fortrend Deal – Could Have Been Worse. It involves a C corporation attempting to have its cake while eating it too, by paying stock-deal tax on an asset sale.
Christopher Bergin, Tax Day – It Just Isn’t Fair (Tax Analysts Blog) “I suppose the only good news is that in the last several days, there have been dozens of items in the news reporting that the IRS is doing fewer audits.”
Kyle Pomerleau, Why Many People are Wrong about Executive Pay and the Corporate Tax Code. “A neutral tax code that properly defines business income would place no restriction on how much a business can deduct in compensation.”
Howard Gleckman, If Congress Lets Firms Expense Investments, It Should Take Away Their Interest Deduction. Fine, if you let them deduct dividends.
Tags: Anthony Nitti, Christopher Bergin, Going Concern, greg mankiw, Howard Gleckman, Instapundit, Janet Novack, Jason Dinesen, Judge Nega, Kyle Pomerleau, megan mcardle, Paul Neiffer, Peter Reilly, Robert D Flach, Russ Fox, tax administration, tax court, TaxGrrrl