Posts Tagged ‘TIGTA’

Tax Roundup, 4/30/2013: Iowa due date edition. Send them your cash, so they can forward it to thieves.

Tuesday, April 30th, 2013 by Joe Kristan
Via Wikipedia

Via Wikipedia

Legislator insists that thieves get $11 million as price of property tax deal.  As Iowans pay their 2012 balances due on today’s state income tax deadline, they may want to take a moment to ponder how careful the legislature is about spending the money they are sending in.

The Des Moines Register reports that Senator Joe Bolkcom demands an increase in the Iowa earned income credit as the price of a property tax bill:

Sen. Joe Bolkcom, D-Iowa City, chairman of the tax-writing Senate Ways and Means Committee, spoke at a Statehouse news conference sponsored by The Coalition for a Better Iowa, which released a booklet with the stories of Iowans who have been helped by the earned income tax credit. About 200,000 Iowa working families receive the tax credit, which assists households with incomes under $45,000.

Senate Democrats want to raise the earned income tax credit from 7 percent now to 20 percent at a cost of about $55 million annually.

Both Sen. Bolkcom and the Register fail to mention the massive fraud rate of the earned income tax credit.  The Treasury Inspector General for Tax Administration this month reported:

The IRS estimates that 21 to 25 percent of EITC payments were issued improperly in Fiscal Year 2012. The dollar value of these improper payments was estimated to be between $11.6 billion and $13.6 billion.

Applying that fraud percentage to Sen. Bolkcom’s proposal will result in $11.5 million to $13.75 million in “improper” — mostly fraudulent — Iowa EITC payments.   Remember that the EITC is a “refundable” credit, which means that if it exceeds your tax, the state writes you a check.  It’s a spending program, a welfare program.

I would say it takes a special kind of legislator to demand $55 million in spending knowing that it’s an appropriation of at least $11 million to thieves, but really it just takes a run-of-the-mill legislator spending your money instead of his own.

The EITC as a poverty trap: phaseouts of the benefit impose stiff marginal tax rates on the working poor.

The EITC as a poverty trap: phaseouts of the benefit impose stiff marginal tax rates on the working poor.

 

Only somebody who doesn’t prepare tax returns would say something this stupid.  The TaxProf links to this from a University of Wisconsin academic:

 This Article analyzes the ongoing structural transformation by observing and explaining the advantages that accrue from pursuing social and regulatory objectives through the tax code. In particular, this Article identifies a number of legislative and normative advantages that tax-embedded policies offer.

The tax law has one important job: to raise revenue.  If this author had ever done business tax returns for a living, she would know what a challenge it is to simply determine taxable income.  If she had ever helped a client through an IRS audit, she would know how difficult it is for the agents to simply work through the accounting, let alone run a bunch of social programs on the side.  The author should be made to spend three years working at a storefront tax prep business to learn the chaos her views cause outside the faculty lounge.

 

Tony Nitti,  Overview Of The New 3.8% Investment Income Tax, Part 2: Passive Activities

Jeremy Scott, Baucus, the Marketplace Fairness Act, and Tax Reform (Tax.com):

Baucus’s shift to the right in the last few months (which people had assumed was positioning for the election next year) has antagonized more than just progressives.  It seems his Senate colleagues are growing frustrated as well. 

And that will severely hamper the chances that a major tax reform bill will make it to the Senate floor.

 

Judge Sentences Widow to Less Than a Minute of Probation in Tax Case (Accounting Today)

TaxGrrrl, Willie Nelson, Who Saved His Career And His House With The IRS Tapes, Turns 80

Nanette Byrnes,  Republicans pursue tax reform, and more  (Tax Break)

 

Brian Strahle,  STATE TAXES:  WHAT WILL MAKE YOUR COMPANY CHANGE – CHOICE or AUDIT NOTICE?  On not being in denial about your exposure to business taxes in other states.

Jack Townsend, a criminal tax defense attorney, offers some wise advise in  Tips to Avoid an IRS Criminal Investigation or, Worse, a Tax Grand Jury Investigation

 

It’s time for Robert D. Flach’s Tuesday Buzz!

 

Always heed tax policy advice from a violent cannibal boxer.  Boxer Mike Tyson TKOs Fox host with talk pro-tax talk (Kay Bell)

Martin Sullivan, To Balance the Budget: Tax Sex Appeal (Tax.com)  Yes. by all means cut my taxes.

 

Share

Tax Roundup, 1/18/2013: Iowan gets 87 months on Ponzi, tax charges.

Friday, January 18th, 2013 by Joe Kristan
87 months?  Holy Cow!

87 months? Holy Cow!

Iowan gets 7 years on Ponzi scheme, tax charges.  An Ottumwa man who used funds he was supposed to invest to finance his online dating life was sentenced yesterday to 87 months in federal prison on federal fraud and tax charges.  John Holtsinger, 52, will serve the federal sentence after he completes a state OWI sentence.

Mr. Holtsinger entered a guilty plea last year.   The indictment said he sold this improbable investment opportunity:

After conducting trades on behalf of investors for a short period of  time, Holtsinger offered and sold investments to the investors in the form of promissory notes.  He represented that the notes would yield high returns with no risk including, but not limited to, what he called an “inheritance investment” that would be invested through his mother and pay out upon her death.  The “inheritance investment” required a $20,000 deposit and was to pay annual returns of 9% with automatic liquidation and payout if the investment dropped below 3% of its initial value.

“High returns with no risk” is a rare beast indeed, nearly as rare as the Unicorn.  I doubt if they show up in Ottumwa very often.

 

IRS stimulates prison system economy by $35 million in 2010.  From a report by the Treasury Inspector General for Tax Administration:

Refund fraud committed by prisoners remains a significant problem for tax administration. The number of fraudulent tax returns filed by prisoners and identified by the IRS has increased from more than 18,000 tax returns in Calendar Year 2004 to more than 91,000 tax returns in Calendar Year 2010. The refunds claimed on these tax returns increased from $68 million to $757 million. Although the IRS prevented the issuance of $722 million in fraudulent tax refunds during Calendar Year 2010, it released more than $35 million.

The new IRS regulation of tax preparers isn’t going to do much for this problem.  (via the TaxProf)

Related: Doing Your Time (Jack Townsend)

 

TaxGrrrl, As We Creep Closer To The Debt Ceiling Limit, Is Your Tax Refund At Risk?

Kay Bell, Government report fuels fear (again) of federal mileage tax proposal

Russ Fox, The Walking Dead Come Back.

Brian Mahany,  Taxpayer Advocate Questions OVDI, FBAR Penalties

David Cay Johnston, Foundering Tax Avoidance (Tax.com)

Paul Neiffer,  Watch Out For Those Retroactive State Tax Gotchas!

Nanette Byrnes, Facebook’s slump hits California’s budget, and more (Tax Break)

Joseph Henchman and Elizabeth Malm, New Report: Gasoline Taxes and Tolls Pay for Only a Fraction of Road Spending (Tax Policy Blog)

Catch your weekend Buzz early!  From Robert D. Flach.

Howard Gleckman,  A Tiny Little Blog Post on a Tiny Little Tax Bracket. (TaxVox).  Hey, I noticed it first!

News you can use:  Retaining CPAs Is As Easy As Letting Them Work in PJs and Attend Boring Meetings, Says Guy (Going Concern)

 

When outsourcing goes too far.  A story of how a model employee outsourced his own job. (Greg Mankiw).  Nice work if you can get paid while some guy in China does the dirty work.

Share

Tax Roundup, 10/23/2012. News of the obvious edition. And…look! Dead squirrels!

Tuesday, October 23rd, 2012 by Joe Kristan

Refundable credits are vulnerable to fraud, and IRS can’t recover the fraudulent payments.  The Treasury Inspector General for Tax Administration discovers the obvious,  reports Accounting Today (my emphasis):

A new report released Monday by the Treasury Inspector General for Tax Administration on refundable tax credits found that they are highly vulnerable to fraud. Refundable tax credits such as the EITC, the Additional Child Tax Credit, the First-Time Homebuyer Credit, and the American Opportunity Tax Credit for education also provide valuable tax breaks for low-income taxpayers and the middle class.

I call foul.  To say the “First-Time Homebuyer Credit” provides “valuable benefits for low-income taxpayers and the middle class” is lazy and dishonest propaganda.  That’s just the Accounting Today reporter’s assertion, and it appears nowhere in the TIGTA report.   The credit poured money into a declining housing market with little effect, other than blowing $30 billion.  The policy behind the other credits is at best arguable, and the benefits aren’t clearly “valuable” to taxpayers as a whole.

TIGTA initiated its audit to determine the effectiveness of efforts by the IRS to recover refundable credits disallowed during post-refund examinations and to consider options the IRS could implement to decrease the issuance of erroneous refundable credits. 

“Because of the susceptibility of these credits to fraud, and the low success rates in recovering erroneous credits once refunds have been issued, the IRS should take every reasonable step possible to identify potentially questionable credits and validate those credits before associated refunds are issued,” said TIGTA Inspector General J. Russell George in a statement.

So Doug Shulman’s IRS isn’t taking every reasonable step to keep from sending cash to thieves?  He’s been too busy terrorizing innocents abroad and setting up a vast, expensive and useless preparer regulation bureaucracy, apparently.

 

Attorney: West Des Moines firm’s outstanding liabilities to be paid soon (Des Moines Register).  The payroll service provider facing large bills for not remitting client payroll taxes timely says they will make good on them:

A West Des Moines human resources provider has paid its 2012 tax liabilities and has the funds necessary to pay off more than $4.8 million liabilities within the next three months, an attorney for the businessman said today

The Internal Revenue Service since 2006 has issued at least 15 tax liens against John Vratsinas and his collection of companies, InFocus Partners, Iowa Construction Logistics and ICL Staffing, according to court documents.

That’s good news for clients who might otherwise have to pay their payroll taxes twice, first to the payroll company and then to the IRS.  The taxman wants its payroll taxes, even when the payroll company already has received them.   Of course payroll providers shouldn’t fall behind on payroll taxes in the first place.  A wise employer will enroll in EFTPS and go online to monitor that the taxes are being paid, even when they outsource the job.

Also from the West Des Moines Patch: Attorney for West Des Moines Payroll Outsourcer Says 2012 Taxes Paid

Related Tax Update coverage here.

 

The TaxProf mentions an academic paper “Ranking State Tax Systems: Progressivity, Adequacy, Efficiency.”  From the abstract:

A good tax system must raise sufficient revenue – and do so fairly, efficiently, transparently, and coherently. How do the tax systems of the states stack up in terms of fairness, adequacy, and neutrality? To answer this question, we assess each state’s relative performance in terms of progressivity, growth, and administrative and economic efficiency.

Iowa rates 32nd by their measure. I think “progressivity” is a poor tool for measuring state tax systems.”Progressivity” is just a weasel-way of saying ”high rates,” which create distortions and inefficiency, like in Iowa, while punishing pass-through businesses.  Any measure that rates the horrendous New York tax system as #1 is absurd.

 

Russ Fox, Bad States for Gamblers

Patrick Temple-West,  Essential reading: Democrats threaten payroll tax cut consensus, and more (Tax Break)

Trish McIntire,  Tax Backup.  Maintain your records.

Kay Bell,  Kiddie tax, gifts and other tax-related items do get 2013 inflation adjustments

William Perez,  IRA Contribution Limits for 2013

 

Brutal Assault on Reason Watch: 

TaxGrrrl,  Final Presidential Debate – Live Blog

Janet Novack,  10 Reasons Reagan Could Cut The Top Tax Rate To 28%, But Romney Can’t

Peter Reilly,  Debate Proceeds Despite Green Party Lawsuit – Hear Jill Stein On Defense Here

Anthony Nitti,  Clearing Up Confusion Created By The Debates: President Obama’s Tax Proposal And The Fate Of The Small Business Owner.  Anthony unfortunately repeats the pointless fact that increasing the Obama plan only affects “2.5 of small business owners.” That’s true when you rate your Shacklee-selling neighbor the same as a business with dozens or even hundreds of employees.

As the Tax Foundation notes, the Obama plan affects a much higher percentage of pass-through income, a more important measure than the number of Schedule C 1040s.  Anthony dismisses this as just a concern of hedge-funds and private equity millionaires.  My pass-through clients would disagree.

 

The Critical Question:  So Jason … How’s that Guidebook About Same-Sex Marriage and Taxes Coming?  (Jason Dinesen)

Stretch your coffee break:  How to Weaponize Office Supplies (Bloomberg Business Week, via Instapundit)

So the dog can do this, but I can’t?  Man cited for backyard squirrel hunt (KCCI.com)

Share

Tax Roundup, 10/16/2012: A rate-cutting tax reform for Iowa? Also: tax season is now really over.

Tuesday, October 16th, 2012 by Joe Kristan

Iowa’s Governor Branstad seems to be serious about this tax reform thing.  From WCFCourier.com:

Gov. Terry Branstad cautioned lawmakers against finding ways to spend the state’s projected budget surplus, while calling Monday for across-the-board tax changes.

Speaking at a Statehouse news conference, Branstad said he’s working on a tax reform proposal to “dramatically” cut personal, corporate and property taxes in the state.

Specifics would be announced later, he said, possibly when he delivers the Condition of the State speech next year.

An automotive representation of Iowa’s income tax.

Iowa’s basic tax system is little changed structurally from the one we had when the Governor took office the first time in 1983.  Substituting rate schedules, you could almost prepare a 2011 Iowa 1040 on 1984 forms.   You wouldn’t even have to substitute the rate schedule to prepare a corporate return; Iowa’s highest-in-the-nation corporation rate is unchanged since 1981.

While the basic structure is unchanged, the system has become infested with special interest deductions and credits over the years — a process that started under Governor Branstad and that got out of control during the 12-year interregnum between his fourth and fifth terms.

In some ways tax reform would be a reversal of course for the Governor.  He has continued the process of complicating the Iowa tax law with special breaks since his return, enacting new carve-outs for ESOPs and proposing special rules for “anchor manufacturers” while making a massive tax credit allocation to the new Southeast Iowa fertilizer plant.

But Governor Branstad also has some history as a tax cutter.   He signed a big rate cut that took effect in 1987, reducing Iowa’s highest individual tax rate from an insane 13% to a still painful 9.98%.  Yet that cut left the basic Iowa structure — including the individual deduction for federal income taxes — untouched.  When he made the huge allocation to the Orascom plant, he was at least embarrassed enough to say that it was an argument for corporate tax reform.

So will the Governor go big?  Will he embrace important elements of the Tax Update’s Quick and Dirty Iowa Tax Teform Plan, which would eliminate Iowa’s corporation tax and cut individual rates to around 4%, while sweeping away the federal income tax deduction and all special carve-outs?  Stay tuned.

Related: Tax Foundation 2013 State Business Tax Climate Index

 

Brutal Assault on Reason Watch: 

CRFB:  Repealing Deductions Could Lead to 30% Tax Rate Cut (Not Merely 20% Claimed by Romney) and Obama’s $49 Billion Tax Increase on Small Business in 2013 (TaxProf)

What the Joint Tax Committee Really Said About Tax Reform (Howard Gleckman, TaxVox)

Because Doug Shulman’s IRS would rather spend its resources licensing preparers than giving tax refunds to struggling businesses: DELAYS IN PROCESSING NET OPERATING LOSS CASES RESULTED IN MILLIONS OF DOLLARS IN UNNECESSARY INTEREST PAYMENTS (TIGTA report)

Anthony Nitti,  Can A Shareholder Own Corporate Goodwill?

Jana Luttenegger,  Basics of Estate Tax and Gift Tax (Davis Brown Tax Law Blog)

Peter ReillyDon’t Freak Out If You Hear Your Trust Is Defective

Trish McIntire,  98 Days and Counting.  98 days for 2012 tax planning.

News you can use:  I GIVE UP!  (Robert D. Flach) “The members of Congress are idiots.  More so now than ever before in our history.”

The Critical Question:  When it comes to auditing, just what does familiarity breed? (Nanette Byrnes)

Paul Neiffer,  Another Tax Season Bites The Dust

Mothers, hide your children.   Tax Professionals To Be Released Into the Wild Later Today (Going Concern). Oops, too late, that happened yesterday.

Oh, and happy Bosses Day.

 

Share

Tax Roundup, 10/4/12: IRS destroys taxpayer ID theft fraud reports. Also: the return of the Brutual Assault on Reason Watch!

Thursday, October 4th, 2012 by Joe Kristan

Because they’re too busy terrorizing Americans abroad who have bank accounts:  The IRS is Not Efficiently or Effectively Processing Identity-Theft Referrals, reports the Treasury Inspector General for Tax Administration.   From Tax Analysts (subscriber link):

     The IRS failed to investigate thousands of reported identity theft cases because taxpayers failed to follow inconsistent and confusing instructions for submitting a form to report tax fraud, the Treasury Inspector General for Tax Administration said in a report released October 3.

     The IRS instructs individuals to use Form 3949-A, “Information Referral,” to report suspected cases of tax fraud, but not identity theft. However, thousands of people have used the form to report identity theft cases because the instructions for the form are confusing, TIGTA said. Before May, the IRS did not have procedures in place for processing the Forms 3949-A that had been used to report identity theft, and in 2010 the IRS destroyed some 3,000 of the forms that had been used to report identity theft because there was no way to process them, the report says.

The explosion of identity theft has been the biggest IRS problem under Commissioner Doug Shulman’s watch.   Yet he has neglected and bungled the response to the thievery of up to $5 billion annually from the taxpayers so he could botch the “amnesties” for offshore bank paperwork foot-faults and build a new and useless preparer regulation bureaucracy.  His term ends soon; the next Commissioner has a lot of repair work to do.

Jack Townsend has more:  TIGTA Report on IRS Processing of Tips of Fraud

 

Brutal Assault on Reason watch.  I hate campaign debates and won’t watch them.  I agree with Arnold Kling:

To me, political campaigns are not sacred events, to be eagerly anticipated and avidly followed.  They are brutal assaults on reason.  I look forward to election season about as much as a gulf coast resident looks forward to hurricane season. 

But others have stronger stomachs:

Howard Gleckman,  What Did We Learn from the Presidential Debate? Not Much.

TaxProf,  Tax Whoppers in Last Night’s Presidential Debate

TaxGrrrl,  First Presidential Debate, 2012 – Live Blog and Romney Promises To Cut Taxpayer Funding For PBS (But Says He Still Loves Big Bird)

Anthony Nitti,  Reactions To Obama Versus Romney; Round 1

 

Bad idea.  The Romney campaign has floated a proposal to cap itemized deductions at $17,000 as a way to reduce tax rates.  That’s a bad idea for many obvious reasons.  If you are going to do that, why even bother?  Just have a $17,000 maximum standard deduction based on income.   By eliminating the deduction for state taxes paid, it would be a big tax increase on pass-through businesses operating in high-tax states.    William McBride at The Tax Policy blog gets it right:

Today Romney proposed to cap itemized deductions at $17,000, as a way to pay for his cut in personal tax rates.  This is not sound tax policy, as it would complicate the code, and likely require a number of exemptions and other loopholes.  For instance, how would legitimate business deductions be dealt with?  Which ones are legitimate? … It would be better to eliminate entirely certain wasteful tax expenditures, while lowering rates.

Other coverage:

Robert D. Flach,  LIMITING ITEMIZED DEDUCTIONS?

Martin Sullivan,  Romney’s Intriguing Idea (Tax.com)

Going Concern,  What Are People Saying About Mitt Romney’s Tax Deduction Cap Idea?

Kay Bell,  Romney suggests overall itemized tax deduction limit of $17,000

 

In non-campaign news:

Peter Reilly,  Navajo Nation Member Treated As New Mexico Resident For Income Tax Purposes

 Trish McIntire,  Kansas Taxing Business Losses

Jason Dinesen,  Would a New Name Help Enrolled Agents?  The new IRS “Registered Tax Return Preparer” designation can only be bad news for Enrolled Agents, whose much more stringent standards are little understood outside the professional world.  Many taxpayers have no idea of the distinction between these IRS-awarded titles.

News you can use: How To Make Partner In Five Easy Steps (or Don’t Give Up Now, Many Partners Are Going To Die Soon) (Going Concern)

 

Share

Tax Roundup, 9/28/2012: If you want to cheat on payroll taxes, get a government job. Plus: tax credits provide a man long-term housing!

Friday, September 28th, 2012 by Joe Kristan

A little personal liability for the unpaid taxes would get the point across.  The TaxProf passes on this nugget from the Treasury Inspector General for Tax Administration:

Federal agencies are exempt from paying Federal income taxes; however, they are not exempt from meeting their employment tax deposits and related reporting requirements. As of December 31, 2011, 70 Federal agencies with 126 delinquent tax accounts owed approximately $14 million in unpaid taxes. In addition, 18 Federal agencies had not filed or were delinquent in filing 39 employment tax returns. Federal agencies should be held to the same filing and paying standards as all American taxpayers.

When private or non-profit employers fail to remit payroll taxes, the IRS can impose personal liability on the “responsible persons” who fail to see that the taxes are paid.   The IRS can go after anyone from executives to bookkeepers to collect the unpaid tax.  It appears from the TIGTA report (page 2) that the IRS can’t or won’t apply this when government agencies are involved.   Another triumph of fairness from Doug Shulman’s IRS.  The TIGTA report recommends steps to address the problem, but tar and feathers would be a good start.

 

Contrast the IRS delinquent tax approach to other agencies with this:

Massachusetts Tax Fraud Promoter Sentenced to Prison for Conspiracy to Obstruct and Impede the IRS

A federal judge in Worcester, Mass., sentenced William Scott Dion today to 84 months in prison for conspiring to defraud the United States, and for obstructing the Internal Revenue Service (IRS), the Justice Department and IRS announced. U.S. District Judge F. Dennis Saylor also ordered Dion to pay restitution in the amount of $3 million. 

According to the evidence presented at trial, Dion, Floyd and Adams ran a payroll tax scheme in order to pay employees “under the table” without properly accounting for, withholding, and paying over to the IRS the payroll taxes required by law.

So a private sector actor gets seven years in the big house for scamming payroll taxes.   When a government agency budgeteer does it… nothing.

Other coverage: Kay Bell,  Uncle Sam owes himself $14 million in unpaid federal agency taxes

 

Think of it as a high-income housing tax credit.   Developer Gets 11 1/2 Years in Bank, Tax Fraud Scheme (HamptonRoads.com).

Eric Menden, the former owner of the Wainwright building and the old James Madison Hotel downtown, was sentenced Wednesday to 11-1/2 years in federal prison after admitting to his role in two fraud schemes that grossed more than $40 million.

Menden, 53, of Chesapeake, pleaded guilty to charges of bank and wire fraud and making false statements. He admitted his role in scamming the state and federal government’s historic tax credit program and to defrauding Bank of the Commonwealth out of tens of millions in a loan scheme.

Even when outright theft isn’t involved, “targeted tax credits” are normally a disreputable transfer from the taxpayers to the well-connected.

 

Howard Gleckman, A Modest Proposal: Five Ways to Tax the 47 Percent (TaxVox). I know he’s trying to show how outrageous it is to try to broaden the income tax base, but his first suggestion — repealing the Earned Income Tax Credit and the Child Tax Credit — is probably a good idea, and it would save the government billions of dollars in fraud losses.

In any case, if spending is not cut, the “47 percent” are going to see a tax increase, probably in the form of a Value Added Tax.  The “rich” simply don’t have enough money to cover the government’s incontinent spending, even if you took all their income.

 

Tax Policy Blog chart of the day:

 

Jack Townsend,  Former IRS Agent Charged with Conflict of Interest and Disclosing Return Information Including Whistleblower Name

Janet Novack,  Former IRS Examiner Charged With Leaking Whistleblower’s Name To Big Bank Target

Trish McIntire,  Livestock Deferment Extended

Russ Fox,   California Musings

Jim Maule, Taxes and Services

No kidding.   Corporate tax avoidance subsides when IRS audit threat increases, study finds (Nanette Byrnes, Tax Break)  Next thing you know, a study will show that motorists slow down when they see a state trooper running radar up ahead.

News you can use:  Cigarette Smuggling Can Make You $4 Million Dollars Richer  (Scott Drenkard, Tax Policy Blog)

Share

Legislators advocate nearly tripling fraud and waste

Friday, March 23rd, 2012 by Joe Kristan

The leaders in the Iowa Senate are pushing to increase Iowa’s Earned Income Tax Credit from 7% of the federal credit to 20%.  A report on the federal credit from the Treasury Inspector General for Tax Administration should give them pause:

The IRS estimates that 21 to 26 percent of EITC payments were issued improperly in Fiscal Year 2011. This equates to $13.7 billion to $16.7 billion in EITC improper payments.

It should give them pause, but it won’t.

Related: Incentives to stay poor

 TIGTA link via the TaxProf

 

Share

Because you can’t trust private agencies to collect taxes

Thursday, November 10th, 2011 by Joe Kristan

The IRS shut down its pilot program to use private collection agencies to pursue some tax delinquents in 2009. We were told the IRS was more effective at collecting the taxes. Now the Treasury Inspector General for Tax Administration has a report showing how that’s worked out:

When the PDC Program was discontinued in March 2009, the IRS recalled cases with a total assessed balance of $848.5 million from the remaining contractors. TIGTA reviewed the effectiveness of collection actions taken by the IRS on taxpayer accounts returned by the PDC Program.
The IRS did not always pursue collection actions on cases returned to the IRS or analyze the best practices of the private debt collection agencies in the PDC Program for possible improvement of IRS collection practices, TIGTA found.

TIGTA reviewed a statistical sample of 62 cases returned in Fiscal Year 2009 and found that collection actions were not taken for 29 (47 percent) of the 62 cases. These cases were not selected for collection action due to collection policies and inventory assignment practices. TIGTA estimates that potentially $30.7 million in collections will remain as outstanding liabilities. In addition, TIGTA estimates that the IRS may not collect an additional $103.2 million per year, or $516 million over the next five years, from similar cases in its inventory that would have otherwise been assigned to the PDC Program.

While I hate to ever agree with politicians, I agree with Senator Grassley’s take, as reported by Tax Analysts ($link):

“The IRS assured us all that the agency could do a better job with these tax cases than outside firms and didn’t need any help. It turns out that the IRS isn’t doing a better job and in many cases, isn’t doing the job at all,” Grassley said in a statement. “The IRS and Treasury Department went out of their way to stop a means of collecting tax debt that the IRS otherwise will never collect. They bowed to union pressure and terminated an alternative collection program before it had a chance to reach its full potential. It’s a shame the IRS continues to let tax debt slide while honest taxpayers pay what they owe. The agency should explain why that’s the case. And the Administration should be focused on collecting existing taxes owed before trying to impose new taxes, as is being suggested in deficit reduction proposals.”

But the lost revenues collections jobs don’t count, because they weren’t Treasury Employee Union jobs anyway.
Related: PRIVATE TAX COLLECTION: A MENACE?
UPDATE 11/14: Kay Bell has more.

Share

It’s complex and confusing. Why isn’t it more popular?

Tuesday, November 8th, 2011 by Joe Kristan

The TaxProf Blog has this headline today:

TIGTA: Only 14% of Eligible Small Businesses Claim ObamaCare Tax Credit

The IRS is just baffled as to why employers might be passing up this tax break:

According to the IRS, as of mid-May 2011, just more than 228,000 taxpayers had claimed the Credit for a total amount of more than $278 million. Among reasons given by industry groups and professional organizations for the low volume was the time and effort required to claim the Credit. The IRS plans to conduct focus groups to determine why the claim rate was so low.

Hey IRS, focus on this:

Click to enlarge
This should give pause to Congresscritters and experts who think that they can nudge us all into optimal behavior (whatever that means) by carefully-calibrated and phased-out targeted tax benefits. But it won’t.

Share

Boy, that home-buyer credit was a great idea

Thursday, October 13th, 2011 by Joe Kristan

From the TaxProf:
TIGTA: 41% Error Rate in $30 Billion First Time Homebuyer Tax Credit Program
From the TIGTA report:

The IRS reported a total of $29.7 billion in Homebuyer Credit claims were made by more than 4 million individuals as of May 7, 2011. Our overall objective was to evaluate the effectiveness of IRS processes to ensure the accurate and timely repayment of the Homebuyer Credit. …
The IRS issued incorrect notices or did not send notices to 61,427 households due to notice programming errors or incorrect information on tax account. … [O]ur review of the third-party vendor

Share

Math is still hard

Friday, August 26th, 2011 by Joe Kristan

TIGTA: IRS Made Math Errors in 17% of its Taxpayer Math Error Adjustments

Share

Remember this next time an IRS examiner writes up your inventory method

Thursday, March 10th, 2011 by Joe Kristan

From a report by the Treasury Inspector General for Tax Administration:

Although CI [IRS Criminal Investigation division] took steps to strengthen controls over its equipment inventory, TIGTA

Share

Shocked. Shocked!

Friday, February 4th, 2011 by Joe Kristan

20110204-1.jpgI’m shocked that non-compliance and fraud is going on here in the electric car tax credit casino! But the Treasury Inspector General for Tax Administration says it is so:

Approximately $33 million in credits for plug-in electric and alternative-fueled vehicles credits were erroneously claimed by at least 12,920 taxpayers through July 24, 2010. … That means about 20% of the $163.9 million in credits claimed by taxpayers from January 1, 2010 to July 24, 2010 for plug-in electric and alternative motor vehicle credits were claimed in error. In the course of its review, TIGTA also found that 1,719 of the 12,920 individuals also erroneously reduced the amount of Alternative Minimum Tax they owed by almost $5.3 million.
According to TIGTA

Share

Why stop prisoner tax fraud when you can beat up on law-abiding preparers?

Wednesday, January 5th, 2011 by Joe Kristan

Interesting set of priorities you have, Commissioner Shulman. You have committed enormous institutional resources to imposing a massive new preparer regulation and registration regime. You are forcing practitioners to spend millions of dollars and hours in pointless paperwork on pain of being put out of business. Meanwhile, you let actual criminals — in prison — steal millions by filing fraudulent tax returns:

The IRS has not shared prisoner tax return information with Federal and State prison officials to help combat tax fraud by inmates. … The Inmate Tax Fraud Prevention Act of 2008, signed October 15, 2008 and amended in July 2010, provides the IRS with the authority to disclose information on prisoners who have filed a false tax return to the head of the Federal Bureau of Prisons and State departments of corrections. The law also requires TIGTA to provide Congress with a report on the IRS

Share

Dead people need a place to live too.

Friday, September 10th, 2010 by Joe Kristan

For some folks who got through life without ever achieving the joys of home ownership, the first-time homebuyer credit gave them a shot at it in the afterlife. From a report of the Treasury Inspector General for Tax Administration:

TIGTA also identified 1,326 single taxpayers the Social Security Administration recorded as deceased who claimed $10.1 million in erroneous Credits. The IRS did not allow 528 of the 1,326 individuals to receive over $4 million they claimed for the Credit.

So what about the other 798? The report says the IRS should:

ensure the 798 individuals who TIGTA identified as being deceased prior to the purchase of the home are entitled to claim the Credit.

So the IRS has auditors beyond the veil? If you run into an IRS agent in the afterlife, you made a serious mistake somewhere along the line.
The TaxProf has more.

Share

Good thing private collection agencies no longer menace taxpayer confidentiality

Wednesday, May 12th, 2010 by Joe Kristan

From the Taxprof:

TIGTA: IRS Releases Confidential Information to Callers Without Proper Authentication in 16% of Cases, Subjecting Taxpayers to Risk of Identity Theft

Peter Pappas has more.
Background: Treasury to shut down private collection

Share

They do what they do so well, let’s give them more to do

Tuesday, April 27th, 2010 by Joe Kristan

TaxProf headline:
TIGTA: IRS Fails to Flag 1.2 Million Tax Returns Evidencing Identity Theft
From the TIGTA press release:

WASHINGTON – An estimated 1.2 million tax returns filed in 2007 reported wages earned by taxpayers who used another taxpayer’s Social Security Number, a sign of possible identity theft, according to a report publicly released today by the Treasury Inspector General for Tax Administration (TIGTA).
The Internal Revenue Service cannot currently identify identity theft cases when taxpayers file tax returns using an Individual Taxpayer Identification Number (ITIN) and use another person’s name and Social Security Number to work, the report found.

This can lead to all sorts of problems. Some are minor, like having an electronic filing rejected because somebody has already filed a return using your Social Security number, or that of one of your dependents. Some are much more serious, including having your tax payments credited to somebody else, and having somebody else’s tax problems end up in your account. But no doubt they will do an excellent job with their additional chores of regulating preparers and running the national health commissariat.
The whole TIGTA report is here. Peter Pappas has more.
Reblog this post [with Zemanta]

Share